I agree We use cookies on this website to help us provide the best user experience. By browsing this site you agree to their use - more information is available here.

Barnett Waddingham
0333 11 11 222
The fiduciary management market has grown considerably over recent years and has brought with it new challenges for pension scheme trustees to address.

While Barnett Waddingham has no intention to enter the market as a provider of fiduciary management services, we are ideally placed to provide an expert independent oversight service to trustees who are considering or who have chosen to go down a fiduciary management route.

Careful analysis of our services and client needs has reinforced our decision to remain independent and to not provide a fiduciary management service.

In essence, we strongly believe that if you get your investment decision making framework right then positive investment outcomes will follow.  For some this might mean a fiduciary management approach, but our view is that in most cases this is best achieved in an environment where the organisations which advise on and implement your investment strategy are independent.

However, we recognise the growth of the fiduciary management market, and that in some cases a provider will offer a service which is the right fit for a particular scheme. In these cases, we strongly believe that the role of independent oversight is essential when hiring a fiduciary manager, setting its mandate and monitoring its performance.

“The service we deliver goes way beyond just oversight and draws from our expertise as one of the UK’s leading independent investment consultancies. Investment performance analytics is a key part of what we do, but it is our long track record in advising on strategy and trustee decision making which enables us to critically evaluate a client’s existing or potential fiduciary management arrangements. Through FM Evaluate, trustees and sponsors can ensure that their pension scheme’s investments are being implemented in the most effective and cost-effective way.”
Peter Daniels

FM Evaluate has been designed to bring the independence and impartiality required to give trustees confidence in their fiduciary management arrangement.

We can add value for trustees in the following areas:

  • training and education – we help trustees understand the different investment governance framework approaches, as well as the different types of fiduciary models, and help work out what is right for them
  • fiduciary manager selection – we help trustees consider the full range of different fiduciary management models and short list providers which will best meet our clients’ needs
  • setting the mandate – we help restore impartiality back to the setting of the fiduciary manager’s mandate by ensuring that appropriate performance benchmarks and investment guidelines are in place
  • performance monitoring – we help trustees judge whether their fiduciary manager is adding value as well as providing a platform for positive challenge, again helping to restore impartiality.

Our service to each set of trustees is bespoke to their specific requirements. We believe this is essential since the expertise and needs of different trustee boards vary considerably.

For further information or to view our latest FM Evaluate services document, please contact Peter Daniels.

Related knowledge and resources


  • Picture for The future of Diversified Growth Funds
    The future of Diversified Growth Funds

    Does the rationale for holding DGFs still hold true? Lower returns – what are the options? Quantitative Easing (QE) has brought forward future returns and has artificially inflated returns over the past five years.

  • Picture for Dealing with a deficit – failing to plan or planning to fail?
    Dealing with a deficit – failing to plan or planning to fail?

    The Pensions Regulator has published its latest annual statement for schemes currently conducting a valuation. Schemes may face increased deficits and the statement sets out TPR’s expectations of trustees and employers. Read more in our latest blog.

  • Picture for Market volatility – back on the radar
    Market volatility – back on the radar

    The Government’s Budget announcement of freedom and choice in pensions may have inadvertently created a tax loophole. What should employers need to think about?

  • CMA - spotlight on fiduciary management

    On 12 December 2018, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published its final report in relation to its review of the market for investment consulting and fiduciary management services.

  • Investment Insights - Equities

    We consider the outlook for equities over the long term and the short term, before considering the options available to investors concerned that equities may be due a fall.

  • Scottish rate of income tax and pension tax relief

    The Scotland Act 2012 gives the Scottish Parliament the power to set the Scottish rate of income tax. As a result, since 6 April 2016, Scottish taxpayers have been subject to lower rates of UK income tax.

Updates delivered to you

Stay ahead with our latest comment, expert insight and event details.